hp_rarefest | (no subject)

You're viewing

hp_rarefest
Create a Dreamwidth Account Learn More

Reload page in style: site light

hpraremod posting in

hp_rarefest

Discussion Question #4
Here is a tough one for you. If you could change one thing in the Harry Potter books, what would it be and why?

Flat | Top-Level Comments Only

From:

vaysh

I would change one thing. It's big, but it's not the Epilogue. I can happily live with EWE fics, and I'd hate to lose the kids.

I'd change DH to tell all the action taking part in Hogwarts from another pov than Harry's. I realise that JK did not want to lose Harry's as the main narrator but plot-wise, it would have made so much more sense to have the Hogwarts parts of DH be told by a narrator who was involved. The pov could have been Ginny (to get a girl's pov for a change) or Luna, or Neville or even Draco (would have been interesting to get a Death Eater's pov, too). JK would have gone for Neville, most likely, and it could have worked awesomely. It is my humble opinion that DH would have been a better book if we were allowed to see the Hogwarts action live, and not be told in hindsight.

Flat | Top-Level Comments Only

Profile

harry potter rare pair fest

December 2017

S	M	T	W	T	F	S
					1	2
3	4	5	6	7	8	9
10	11	12	13	14	15	16
17	18	19	20	21	22	23
24	25	26	27	28	29	30
31

Most Popular Tags

!2012 fest - 75 uses
!2013 fest - 57 uses
!2014 fest - 45 uses
!2015 fest - 52 uses
!2016 fest - 49 uses
!2017 fest - 55 uses
!anonymous masterlist - 7 uses
!claiming - 6 uses
!discussion question - 18 uses
!fest masterlist - 6 uses
!mod - 80 uses
!pimping: other comm - 15 uses
!prompting - 8 uses
!prompts - 12 uses
!weekly round-up - 22 uses
-art - 46 uses
-femmeslash - 33 uses
-fic - 196 uses
-het - 80 uses
-slash - 113 uses
-threesome - 13 uses
character: albus severus potter - 12 uses
character: blaise zabini - 11 uses
character: charlie weasley - 11 uses
character: draco malfoy - 34 uses
character: ginny weasley - 21 uses
character: harry potter - 47 uses
character: hermione granger - 24 uses
character: james sirius potter - 8 uses
character: lucius malfoy - 6 uses
character: luna lovegood - 14 uses
character: neville longbottom - 11 uses
character: oliver wood - 6 uses
character: pansy parkinson - 24 uses
character: percy weasley - 9 uses
character: regulus black - 12 uses
character: remus lupin - 23 uses
character: ron weasley - 11 uses
character: scorpius malfoy - 7 uses
character: severus snape - 7 uses
character: sirius black - 15 uses
character: teddy lupin - 16 uses
character: theodore nott - 6 uses
pairing: ginny/luna - 6 uses
pairing: regulus/remus - 6 uses
rating: g - 17 uses
rating: nc-17 - 106 uses
rating: pg - 16 uses
rating: pg-13 - 45 uses
rating: r - 44 uses

Page Summary

vaysh - re: If you could change one thing in the Harry Potter books, what would it be and why?

Style Credit

Base style: Corinthian by momijizukamori
Theme: Trust Fall by zaluzianskya

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags

Page generated Feb. 17th, 2026 02:24 pm

Powered by Dreamwidth Studios